The 4 Best Omega-3 Supplements: Fish Oil vs Krill Oil Comparison 2025

The 4 Best Omega-3 Supplements of 2025

Fish Oil vs Krill Oil: Expert comparison for heart health, brain function, and inflammation support

Nutritionist Reviewed | ⏰ Last Updated: January 2025 | 🔬 Evidence-Based

🐟 Fish Oil vs 🦐 Krill Oil: Which Is Better?

🐟 Fish Oil Benefits

  • Higher EPA/DHA content per serving
  • More research backing health benefits
  • Lower cost per mg of omega-3s
  • Widely available in various forms
  • Proven cardiovascular and brain benefits

🦐 Krill Oil Benefits

  • Superior absorption (phospholipid form)
  • Astaxanthin antioxidant included naturally
  • No fishy burps or aftertaste
  • Better bioavailability than fish oil
  • Sustainable harvesting practices

📊 Quick Comparison Table

Product Type EPA/DHA Price Best For Rating Buy Now
Nordic Naturals Ultimate Omega
Nordic Naturals Ultimate Omega
60 Soft Gels
Fish Oil 1280mg $20-25 Overall Best ★★★★★
4.6/5
Buy Now
Doctor's Best Antarctic Krill Oil
Doctor's Best Antarctic Krill
60 Softgels
Krill Oil 800mg $15-20 Best Krill ★★★★☆
4.3/5
Buy Now
Thorne Super EPA
Thorne Super EPA
90 Gelcaps
Fish Oil 695mg $35-40 High EPA ★★★★★
4.5/5
Buy Now
Source Naturals NKO Neptune Krill Oil
Source Naturals NKO Neptune
60 Softgels
Krill Oil 500mg $20-25 Best Value ★★★★☆
4.4/5
Buy Now

🔍 Detailed Product Reviews

BEST OVERALL

Nordic Naturals Ultimate Omega

Nordic Naturals Ultimate Omega
$21.99
60 soft gels
($0.37/serving)

Why We Chose This:

Nordic Naturals is the #1 selling omega-3 brand in the US, known for exceptional purity and freshness. Their Ultimate Omega provides concentrated EPA and DHA in the superior triglyceride form, with a pleasant lemon flavor that eliminates fishy burps.

Key Features:

  • 1280mg total omega-3s per serving
  • Lemon flavor - no fishy taste
  • Triglyceride form for better absorption
  • Made from wild-caught fish
  • Third-party tested for purity
✓ Pros
  • Highest omega-3 concentration
  • No fishy burps or aftertaste
  • Excellent third-party testing
  • Sustainable sourcing practices
  • Pleasant lemon flavor
✗ Cons
  • Larger capsule size
  • More expensive per serving
  • Contains gelatin (not vegan)
🩺 Health Benefits:
  • Heart Health: Reduces triglycerides
  • Brain Function: Improves memory & focus
  • Anti-Inflammatory: Reduces inflammation
  • Eye Health: Supports retinal function
  • Joint Support: Reduces stiffness
  • Mood Balance: Helps depression & anxiety
⚠️ Important Notes:
  • Take with food for better absorption
  • Consult doctor if taking blood thinners
  • Store in cool, dry place
BEST KRILL OIL

Doctor's Best Antarctic Krill Oil

Doctor's Best Antarctic Krill Oil
$15.29
60 softgels
($0.25/serving)

Why We Chose This:

Doctor's Best uses authentic Superba2 krill oil, the most researched krill oil brand. The phospholipid-bound omega-3s offer superior absorption compared to fish oil, while natural astaxanthin provides powerful antioxidant protection.

Key Features:

  • Superba2 krill oil - premium grade
  • 800mg omega-3s in phospholipid form
  • Natural astaxanthin antioxidant
  • Superior bioavailability
  • Non-GMO and gluten-free
✓ Pros
  • Superior bioavailability
  • Natural astaxanthin included
  • No fishy aftertaste
  • Smaller capsule size
  • Excellent value for krill oil
✗ Cons
  • Lower total omega-3 content
  • More expensive per mg
  • Contains shellfish allergen
🦐 Krill Oil Advantages:
  • Better Absorption: 3x more bioavailable
  • Astaxanthin Power: Natural antioxidant
  • No Fishy Burps: Easier on stomach
  • Sustainable: Eco-friendly harvesting
  • Cell Support: Direct cell integration
  • Women's Health: Benefits PMS symptoms
⚠️ Important Notes:
  • Avoid if allergic to shellfish
  • Consult doctor if taking anticoagulants
  • Take 2 softgels daily with meals
PROFESSIONAL GRADE

Thorne Super EPA

Thorne Super EPA
$40.00
90 gelcaps
($0.44/serving)

Why We Chose This:

Thorne is the supplement brand trusted by healthcare professionals and elite athletes. Their Super EPA provides the highest concentration of EPA per capsule, making it ideal for those targeting inflammation, heart health, and athletic performance.

Key Features:

  • 425mg EPA + 270mg DHA per capsule
  • Professional-grade purity
  • Third-party certified
  • NSF Sport certified
  • Gluten, dairy, and soy-free
✓ Pros
  • Highest EPA concentration
  • Professional-grade quality
  • NSF Sport certified
  • Excellent third-party testing
  • Trusted by healthcare pros
✗ Cons
  • Most expensive option
  • Some report fishy burps
  • Larger capsule size
💊 Professional Benefits:
  • High EPA Ratio: Optimal for inflammation
  • Healthcare Grade: Trusted by 45,000+ pros
  • Sport Certified: NSF tested
  • Molecular Distillation: Removes contaminants
  • Stability Testing: Guaranteed potency
  • Research Backed: Clinical formulation
⚠️ Important Notes:
  • Take 1 gelcap 2-3 times daily
  • Best taken with meals
  • Consult healthcare provider if pregnant
BEST VALUE

Source Naturals NKO Neptune Krill Oil

Source Naturals NKO Neptune Krill Oil
$22.38
60 softgels
($0.37/serving)

Why We Chose This:

Source Naturals uses authentic Neptune Krill Oil (NKO), the original krill oil used in clinical research. This provides an excellent entry point into krill oil benefits at a more affordable price point while maintaining quality and effectiveness.

Key Features:

  • Authentic Neptune krill oil (NKO)
  • 500mg krill oil per softgel
  • Natural phospholipids and astaxanthin
  • Supports heart and cell membrane health
  • Sustainable Antarctic sourcing
✓ Pros
  • Authentic NKO brand
  • Excellent value for money
  • No fishy aftertaste
  • Easy to swallow
  • Clinically studied formula
✗ Cons
  • Lower omega-3 concentration
  • Bottle has fishy smell
  • Less potent than premium options
💰 Value Benefits:
  • Authentic NKO: Original Neptune krill oil
  • Great Price: Affordable krill oil entry
  • Proven Formula: Used in clinical studies
  • Easy Digestion: No fishy burps
  • Quality Sourcing: Sustainably harvested
  • Versatile: Multiple health benefits
⚠️ Important Notes:
  • Contains shellfish - avoid if allergic
  • Take 1-2 softgels daily with food
  • Store in cool, dry place

🎯 Which Omega-3 Should You Choose?

Choose Nordic Naturals if:

You want the highest omega-3 concentration with proven quality and no fishy taste

Choose Doctor's Best if:

You prefer superior absorption and want the benefits of astaxanthin antioxidant

Choose Thorne if:

You need professional-grade quality with the highest EPA concentration for inflammation

Choose Source Naturals if:

You want to try krill oil benefits at an affordable price with authentic NKO formula

Remember: The best omega-3 supplement is the one you'll take consistently. All four options provide excellent health benefits when taken as directed.

⚖️ Legal Disclaimers

Amazon Affiliate Disclosure: This website contains affiliate links to Amazon.com. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you. We only recommend products we genuinely believe in.

Medical Disclaimer: The information provided is for educational purposes only and is not intended as medical advice. These statements have not been evaluated by the FDA. These products are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease. Always consult your healthcare provider before starting any supplement regimen.

Product Information: Prices and availability are subject to change. Product information is based on manufacturer specifications and may vary. Always read product labels and follow manufacturer instructions.